top of page

IN SCOTTSDALE, THE PLAN IS WORTH MORE THAN THE HOUSE

4 hours ago
3 min read

Every loan we funded in October was in Scottsdale. In every one, the operator was really buying a plan, not a house.


FROM DEVON’S DESK: THE OCTOBER LENDING DESK

Phoenix home values are basically flat. Zillow’s latest read puts the typical metro home at $440,821, down 1.1% from a year ago.


In a flat market, nobody is waiting for appreciation to bail out a deal. Value has to be made. Scottsdale has the widest gap between a dated house and a finished one on the same street, so that is where the plan is worth the most right now.


Here is what crossed the desk in October:

  • North Scottsdale (85254): $1,345,000 acquisition. The as-is value is $1.695M, and a ground-up build is planned with a projected value of $6.97M. Repeat borrower.

  • North Scottsdale (85254): $1,350,000 refinance with a $700,000 renovation budget. As-is value is $1.2M, and the projected value is $2.5M.

  • South Scottsdale (85257): $700,000 purchase + rehab. As-is value is $395,000, the rehab budget is $355,000, and the projected value is $1.1M.


Put the planned work next to what each house was worth as-is. On every deal, the work was more than half the house’s value. On the ground-up, it was about 1.8 times.


We do not just lend on the house. We lend on the plan, and on the person running it.


Got a dated house and a big plan? Send it over. I will run the numbers on it as the market works today and give you feedback → www.borrowfrom42.com


THE DEAL DESK: SOUTH SCOTTSDALE (85257)

A big plan only works if the margin survives a miss. Here is how this one holds up. We assumed interest on the full $700K from day one, 1 point, about $8K in closing costs, and 6% to sell. These figures are before taxes, insurance, and utilities.


If it sells at $1.1M:

  • 6 months: $227K profit

  • 9 months: $206K profit

  • 12 months: $185K profit


If it sells 10% low ($990K):

  • 6 months: $124K profit

  • 9 months: $103K profit

  • 12 months: $82K profit


Even the worst corner, a 10% miss plus a full year, still shows about $82K in profit. That margin is what earns a 12-month timeline.


WHAT PAID OFF

  • Sun City: paid off Oct 30, 170 days after funding.

  • Tucson ($635K loan): paid off Oct 30, 422 days after funding.


The 8 loans we funded in 2026 that have already sold averaged 108 days, and every one was under $400K.


That last number comes with an honest caveat: smaller projects finish first.


That is the point. A Sun City flip and a North Scottsdale ground-up are both good business. They run on different clocks, so price each one for its own.


THE DESK, YEAR TO DATE

$20.15M funded across 34 loans in 2026, already 86% more than all of 2025 ($10.8M).


90 loans and $38.2M funded since we started.


Scottsdale is not a rule. It is what came in the door last month. Next up: Surprise, AZ.


ONE THING TO STEAL: the plan-to-house ratio


Divide your planned rehab or build budget by the house’s as-is value.

  • Under 25%: cosmetic. Price it for a short clock.

  • 25% to 50%: real renovation. Plan for permits, surprises, and a longer hold.

  • Over 50%: you are running a construction project. Underwrite a 12-month hold and a 10% miss, and make sure the profit still justifies the risk.

The ratio does not tell you whether a deal is good. It tells you which business you are in.


If you flip or build: know your ratio before you make the offer.


If you are an agent: the dated listing nobody wants may be the best house on the street for your investor clients. Bring them comps for the finished homes nearby.


If you are a contractor: projects over 50% need someone who can hold a budget for 9 to 12 months. Be that contractor.


If you are in title or escrow: you see the before-and-after resales firsthand. Your investor clients would love to hear what you are seeing.


One question I would like answered: what is the highest plan-to-house ratio you have ever run, and would you do it again?


Reply to this email, or call or text 602-501-1174. We lend our own money, so when we say yes, we close.


P.S. In a flat market, the plan is the profit. Price it like one. Send me your next deal → www.borrowfrom42.com Know an operator eyeing a full gut this winter? Forward this to them.


Newsletter Edition #43

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page